Pilgrims & Mayflower Trivia -- 50 Questions

Quick Answer

The Pilgrims' voyage on the Mayflower and their settlement at Plymouth is the foundation of Thanksgiving mythology. This page has 50 questions about the passengers, the journey, the Mayflower Compact, and early colony life.

From the leaking Speedwell to the signing of the Mayflower Compact, from William Bradford's chronicle to Myles Standish's military leadership -- these 50 questions explore every aspect of the Pilgrim experience. Primary-source based and historically accurate.

1. How many passengers departed on the Mayflower from England?
Reveal Answer

102 passengers and about 30 crew. The passengers included men, women, children, and servants.

2. What was the Mayflower's original cargo before passengers?
Reveal Answer

Wine and other goods between England and France. The Mayflower was a merchant vessel, not designed for passengers.

3. What was the intended destination of the Mayflower?
Reveal Answer

The mouth of the Hudson River (then part of Virginia Colony). Storms pushed the ship to Cape Cod instead.

4. What date was the Mayflower Compact signed?
Reveal Answer

November 11, 1620 (Old Style) / November 21, 1620 (New Style). It was signed aboard the ship before landing.

5. How many men signed the Mayflower Compact?
Reveal Answer

41 adult male passengers. All pledged loyalty to the crown and agreed to form a civil government.

6. What was the name of the Pilgrims' church in England before exile?
Reveal Answer

They worshipped in secret as Separatists, not at an official church. The Scrooby congregation met at William Brewster's home.

7. Where did the Pilgrims live before sailing to America?
Reveal Answer

Leiden, Netherlands (1609-1620). They fled England for religious freedom before deciding to sail to the New World.

8. Why did the Pilgrims leave the Netherlands?
Reveal Answer

They feared losing their English identity and their children were assimilating into Dutch culture. Economic hardship also motivated the move.

9. What was the Speedwell?
Reveal Answer

The smaller ship intended to accompany the Mayflower. It leaked twice and was abandoned in England.

10. Who was Christopher Jones?
Reveal Answer

The Mayflower's captain. Jones captained the ship for its famous voyage and died in 1622.

11. How long did the Mayflower voyage take?
Reveal Answer

66 days. The ship departed September 16, 1620, and sighted Cape Cod on November 9, 1620.

12. What disease killed many passengers during the voyage?
Reveal Answer

Scurvy, pneumonia, and possibly typhus. Malnutrition and cramped conditions weakened the passengers.

13. Who was the first person to die on the voyage?
Reveal Answer

William Butten, a teenage servant. He died at sea on November 16, 1620.

14. What was the first child born on the Mayflower?
Reveal Answer

Oceanus Hopkins. Born at sea in late 1620, he died before age two.

15. What was the 'First Encounter'?
Reveal Answer

The Pilgrims' first hostile meeting with Native Americans at Cape Cod in December 1620. The Nauset attacked the exploring party.

16. What was the 'Great Dying' and how did it affect Plymouth settlement?
Reveal Answer

An epidemic that killed up to 90% of coastal Natives between 1616-1619. It cleared land and weakened tribes the Pilgrims later encountered.

17. Who was William Bradford?
Reveal Answer

The long-time governor of Plymouth Colony and author of 'Of Plymouth Plantation.' Bradford governed for over 30 years.

18. What is 'Of Plymouth Plantation'?
Reveal Answer

Bradford's historical chronicle written between 1630 and 1651. It is the primary source for early Plymouth history.

19. Who was John Carver?
Reveal Answer

The first governor of Plymouth Colony. Carver was elected in 1620 but died in April 1621, likely from sunstroke or heat exhaustion.

20. Who was Myles Standish?
Reveal Answer

The colony's military captain. Standish was hired for his military experience and played a key role in the colony's defense.

21. What was the 'Wessagusset affair'?
Reveal Answer

Myles Standish led a preemptive attack on the Nemasket in 1623. The brutal killings permanently damaged Pilgrim-Native relations.

22. Who was Tisquantum (Squanto)?
Reveal Answer

A Patuxet man who served as interpreter for the Pilgrims. He had been kidnapped to Europe and learned English.

23. How did Squanto end up in Europe?
Reveal Answer

He was captured by Thomas Hunt in 1614 and sold into slavery in Spain. He escaped to England and eventually returned home.

24. What role did Samoset play?
Reveal Answer

An Abenaki sagamore who first approached the Pilgrims in English on March 16, 1621. He had learned English from fishermen.

25. What was Massasoit's role?
Reveal Answer

He was the sachem (leader) of the Wampanoag Confederacy. Massasoit maintained peace with the Pilgrims for decades.

26. What was the name of the abandoned Wampanoag village the Pilgrims settled?
Reveal Answer

Patuxet. The village had been wiped out by the 1616-1619 epidemic, leaving cleared fields.

27. What was the 'Three Sisters' planting method?
Reveal Answer

Corn, beans, and squash grown together. The Wampanoag taught the Pilgrims this sustainable companion planting technique.

28. What was the first corn harvest like for the Pilgrims?
Reveal Answer

Successful with Wampanoag help. The 1621 harvest ensured the colony would not starve, prompting the feast.

29. How many people attended the first Thanksgiving?
Reveal Answer

Approximately 50 Pilgrims and 90 Wampanoag men. The event lasted three days.

30. What games were played at the first Thanksgiving?
Reveal Answer

Military demonstrations, foot races, and ball games. Edward Winslow mentions the men exercised with arms and played games.

31. What was the 'Plymouth Council for New England'?
Reveal Answer

The joint-stock company holding the Pilgrims' land patent. It replaced the Virginia Company of Plymouth.

32. What was a 'Pilgrim's daily ration'?
Reveal Answer

Cornmeal, fish, and whatever game or produce was available. Early years were marked by scarcity and rationing.

33. What was the 'Beaver Trade'?
Reveal Answer

Plymouth's primary export to England. Beaver pelts were highly valued in Europe and funded the colony's imports.

34. What was the 'Old Colony Club'?
Reveal Answer

A social club founded in 1769 that celebrated 'Forefathers' Day.' The club preserved Pilgrim memory before Thanksgiving became national.

35. What is Forefathers' Day?
Reveal Answer

A December 22 observance marking the Pilgrims' landing at Plymouth. Older than Thanksgiving, it commemorates the 1620 arrival.

36. What was the 'Pilgrim Tercentenary'?
Reveal Answer

The 300th anniversary celebration in 1920-1921. It included parades, pageants, and the construction of the Plymouth Rock portico.

37. What was the 'Mayflower II'?
Reveal Answer

A replica of the Mayflower launched in 1956. Built in Devon, England, it sailed to Plymouth, Massachusetts, and is now a museum ship.

38. What is the General Society of Mayflower Descendants?
Reveal Answer

A hereditary organization founded in 1897. Membership requires documented descent from a Mayflower passenger.

39. How many Mayflower passengers have confirmed descendants today?
Reveal Answer

Approximately 25-30 of the 102 passengers. Millions of Americans claim Mayflower ancestry.

40. What happened to Plymouth Rock in 1774?
Reveal Answer

Patriots tried to move it and broke it in half. The broken half was moved to Pilgrim Hall; the rest stayed at the waterfront.

41. When was the current Plymouth Rock structure built?
Reveal Answer

1920. The granite portico enclosing Plymouth Rock was built for the Pilgrim Tercentenary.

42. What was the 'Pilgrims' Progress' book?
Reveal Answer

A Christian allegory by John Bunyan (1678), unrelated to the Pilgrims. Despite the name, Bunyan was an English Baptist, not a Plymouth colonist.

43. What was the 'Plymouth Antiquarian Society'?
Reveal Answer

Founded in 1919 to preserve Pilgrim artifacts and historic houses. It operates several historic properties in Plymouth.

44. What is the 'Scrooby congregation'?
Reveal Answer

The group of Separatists who met at William Brewster's home in Scrooby, England. They were the core of the future Pilgrims.

45. Who was William Brewster?
Reveal Answer

An elder of the Scrooby congregation and a leader at Plymouth. Brewster served as the colony's religious leader and negotiated with the Wampanoag.

46. What was the 'Leiden congregation'?
Reveal Answer

The Pilgrims' community in the Netherlands from 1609-1620. About 300 Separatists lived in Leiden before some sailed to America.

47. What was the 'New England' name origin?
Reveal Answer

Captain John Smith coined it in 1616. Smith mapped the region and named it New England to encourage settlement.

48. What was the 'Great Migration' of 1630?
Reveal Answer

The Puritan migration to Massachusetts Bay. About 20,000 Puritans arrived in the 1630s, far exceeding the Pilgrims' numbers.

49. What was the 'Pilgrim Tercentenary Half Dollar'?
Reveal Answer

A commemorative coin issued in 1920-1921. The U.S. Mint produced 152,000 half dollars to mark the 300th anniversary of Plymouth.

50. What is the 'Plymouth Archaeological Rediscovery Project'?
Reveal Answer

An effort to locate the original 1620 settlement through archaeology. Since 2013, researchers have found artifacts from the first Pilgrim homes.

Host a Thanksgiving Trivia Night Tonight

Ready-to-play Thanksgiving trivia packs with questions, answer sheets, and hosting guides. Perfect for family gatherings, office parties, and Friendsgiving celebrations. Download instantly.

Browse Thanksgiving Trivia Packs

Want a Complete Thanksgiving Trivia Pack?

Skip the prep work. Get professionally formatted Thanksgiving trivia with answer sheets and a hosting guide -- ready to play at your dinner table in minutes.

Get Thanksgiving Trivia Packs