Thanksgiving Dessert Trivia -- 40 Questions

Quick Answer

Pumpkin, pecan, apple, sweet potato -- Thanksgiving desserts are iconic. This page has 40 questions about pie history, regional specialties, baking science, and the sweetest side of the holiday.

The dessert table is where Thanksgiving truly shines. These 40 questions cover pumpkin pie spice chemistry, pecan pie origins, regional specialties like shoofly pie and chess pie, and the world record for the biggest pumpkin pie. Sweet tooths, dig in.

1. What is the most popular Thanksgiving dessert?
Reveal Answer

Pumpkin pie. Over 50 million pumpkin pies are eaten each Thanksgiving.

2. What are the three most popular Thanksgiving pies?
Reveal Answer

Pumpkin, pecan, and apple. These three dominate holiday dessert tables.

3. What spice is essential in pumpkin pie?
Reveal Answer

Pumpkin pie spice. A blend of cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, allspice, and cloves.

4. What is the origin of pumpkin pie?
Reveal Answer

Early American colonists adapted English custard pies using native pumpkins. The first pumpkin pie recipes appeared in 17th-century cookbooks.

5. What is pecan pie's main sweetener?
Reveal Answer

Corn syrup. Traditional pecan pie uses light or dark corn syrup, sugar, butter, and eggs.

6. What state produces the most pecans?
Reveal Answer

Georgia. Georgia leads U.S. pecan production by a wide margin.

7. What is sweet potato pie popular in?
Reveal Answer

African American and Southern cuisine. It is a beloved alternative to pumpkin pie.

8. What is the difference between sweet potato pie and pumpkin pie?
Reveal Answer

Sweet potato pie uses roasted sweet potatoes instead of pumpkin. It has a denser, richer texture.

9. What is mincemeat pie made from today?
Reveal Answer

Dried fruits, spices, and sometimes beef suet. Modern mincemeat rarely contains actual meat.

10. What is shoofly pie?
Reveal Answer

A molasses pie from Pennsylvania Dutch country. It has a sweet, sticky filling with a crumb topping.

11. What is chess pie?
Reveal Answer

A simple Southern pie made with sugar, butter, eggs, and cornmeal. It is a staple of Southern baking.

12. What is the purpose of blind baking a pie crust?
Reveal Answer

To pre-bake the crust before adding wet filling. This prevents a soggy bottom.

13. What is 'whipped cream' also called?
Reveal Answer

Chantilly cream. When sweetened and flavored with vanilla.

14. What is the difference between ice cream and gelato?
Reveal Answer

Gelato has less fat and less air. It is denser and creamier than American-style ice cream.

15. What is bread pudding made from?
Reveal Answer

Stale bread, eggs, milk, sugar, and spices. It transforms leftover bread into a rich dessert.

16. What nut is used in black walnut ice cream and pie?
Reveal Answer

Black walnuts. Native to North America, they have a stronger, earthier flavor.

17. What is ambrosia salad?
Reveal Answer

A fruit and coconut salad with marshmallows. Common in the South, it includes mandarin oranges and pineapple.

18. What is the world record for the largest pumpkin pie?
Reveal Answer

3,699 pounds, made in Ohio in 2010. It was 20 feet in diameter.

19. What is 'pumpkin pie spice' history?
Reveal Answer

McCormick introduced a pre-mixed blend in the 1930s. Before that, home cooks mixed their own.

20. What is the most popular pie crust type?
Reveal Answer

All-butter or butter-shortening combination. Butter provides flavor; shortening adds flakiness.

21. What is a 'pie bird'?
Reveal Answer

A ceramic vent placed in the center of a pie. It allows steam to escape and prevents filling from boiling over.

22. What is the origin of apple pie as an American symbol?
Reveal Answer

19th-century marketing and WWII patriotism. 'As American as apple pie' became popular during the war.

23. What is a 'slab pie'?
Reveal Answer

A shallow pie baked in a rectangular pan. It serves more people and has a higher crust-to-filling ratio.

24. What is 'candied yams' vs. sweet potato pie?
Reveal Answer

Candied yams are baked sweet potatoes with sugar; sweet potato pie is a custard pie. Both use the same main ingredient.

25. What is 'buttermilk pie'?
Reveal Answer

A custard pie with buttermilk, sugar, and butter. Popular in the South, it has a tangy-sweet flavor.

26. What is 'Jefferson Davis pie'?
Reveal Answer

A Southern pie with pecans, coconut, and raisins. Named after the Confederate president.

27. What is 'derby pie'?
Reveal Answer

A Kentucky chocolate and walnut pie. The name is trademarked by Kern's Kitchen.

28. What is 'coconut cream pie'?
Reveal Answer

A custard pie with coconut in the filling and topping. It is a diner and potluck classic.

29. What is 'banana cream pie'?
Reveal Answer

A custard pie with sliced bananas and whipped cream. It is a mid-20th-century American classic.

30. What is 'key lime pie' doing at Thanksgiving?
Reveal Answer

It is a Florida specialty sometimes served as a lighter alternative. Not traditional, but popular in warm climates.

31. What is 'chocolate pecan pie'?
Reveal Answer

Pecan pie with chocolate chips or syrup added. It combines two favorite flavors.

32. What is 'maple pecan pie'?
Reveal Answer

Pecan pie with maple syrup replacing corn syrup. A Northern variation using local syrup.

33. What is 'brown sugar pie'?
Reveal Answer

A simple pie with a brown sugar custard filling. Popular in Indiana and the Midwest.

34. What is 'sugar cream pie' (Hoosier pie)?
Reveal Answer

Indiana's official state pie. It contains sugar, cream, and flour in a simple custard.

35. What is 'Osgood pie'?
Reveal Answer

A Kentucky pie with raisins, pecans, and coconut. Similar to Jefferson Davis pie.

36. What is 'possum pie' in Arkansas?
Reveal Answer

A layered pie with cream cheese, chocolate, and whipped topping. The name refers to 'playing possum' — hiding the layers.

37. What is 'lemon meringue pie' at Thanksgiving?
Reveal Answer

A tangy alternative for those who dislike sweet pies. Not traditional, but refreshing after a heavy meal.

38. What is 'crumble' vs. 'crisp' vs. 'cobbler'?
Reveal Answer

Crumble has no oats; crisp has oats; cobbler has a biscuit topping. All are fruit desserts with different toppings.

39. What is 'pandowdy'?
Reveal Answer

A New England apple dessert with a broken pastry top. The crust is 'dowdied' or pushed down into the fruit.

40. What is 'grunt' or 'slump'?
Reveal Answer

A New England fruit dessert with dumplings steamed on top. Named for the sound it makes while cooking.

Host a Thanksgiving Trivia Night Tonight

Ready-to-play Thanksgiving trivia packs with questions, answer sheets, and hosting guides. Perfect for family gatherings, office parties, and Friendsgiving celebrations. Download instantly.

Browse Thanksgiving Trivia Packs

Want a Complete Thanksgiving Trivia Pack?

Skip the prep work. Get professionally formatted Thanksgiving trivia with answer sheets and a hosting guide -- ready to play at your dinner table in minutes.

Get Thanksgiving Trivia Packs